Your organisation's volunteers might also be your donors. Does anyone know?

"Staff don't see the value of volunteers." I hear a version of this in many organisations I work with. Teams treat volunteers as extra supervision. Volunteers feel tolerated rather than welcomed. The volunteer manager spends their energy smoothing it over.

It's a long-standing pattern. In the 2020 Volunteer Management Progress Report , leaders of volunteers ranked respect and buy-in from co-workers and leadership as their second biggest challenge.

The usual responses make sense. Train staff to work with volunteers. Report on impact. Involve teams in designing the roles that support their work. These all help. They also skip a question most organisations have never asked: how many of the people who volunteer here also give us money?

Volunteers are already among your most committed supporters

The Giving Australia 2016 research found a strong link between volunteers and philanthropy. In that research, 87.4% of volunteers donated compared with 75.6% of non-volunteers. Among those who donated, volunteers gave an average of $1,017 and non-volunteers $537. They were also more likely to have a will and more likely to have left a charitable bequest. The data is from 2016.

The reason makes sense. People give to organisations they know, trust and believe can make a difference. Nobody knows your organisation from the inside like the person who turns up every Tuesday.

That reach goes beyond the volunteer. A good experience travels to their family, their workplace and their friends. So does a poor one.

Volunteers and philanthropy: why most leaders can't see the connection

In most organisations I work with, volunteer records sit in one system, and donor records sit in another. Two teams, two budgets, two reporting lines. Nobody owns the whole relationship with the person who gives both time and money.

So leadership sees volunteering as a cost line and fundraising as an income line. For many supporters, they're the same relationship.

This is where staff resistance starts to make sense. If the only story a team hears about volunteers is the supervision they need, of course they'll push back. The resistance is a symptom. The missing data is the problem.

What volunteer experience has to do with funding

Volunteer experience is organisational data . When volunteering is rewarding, the relationship deepens. A volunteer becomes a regular donor, brings in workplace giving , introduces a philanthropist or leaves a bequest.

When the experience is frustrating, the cost doesn't show up in the volunteer program's numbers. Slow onboarding, an unwelcoming team or a role that doesn't fit can end a relationship worth far more than the hours on the roster. That's funding and reputational exposure most boards never see, because nobody has connected the two sets of records.

I led a government-commissioned project on business and philanthropy in the context of volunteering in Victoria. Josephine Beer, Manager Volunteering at the Victorian Department of Health, said:

“Christine led a project commissioned by government to assess business and philanthropy in the context of volunteering in Victoria. Christine’s strategic thinking and her stakeholder engagement skills were critical for this work. The work is an important contribution to the development of a Victorian Volunteer Strategy.”

Read what other clients say .

Five questions to take to your fundraising team

  1. How many current and past volunteers are also donors?
  2. What have volunteers given as a group over the past three years?
  3. Have any volunteers told you about a bequest? Did any bequestors once volunteer?
  4. Have volunteers connected you to workplace giving, corporate support, in-kind goods or a philanthropist?
  5. Who owns the relationship with someone who both volunteers and donates?

Aggregate figures are enough to show the pattern. Work with your fundraising team on what your privacy obligations allow before you match any records.

What to do with what you find

Share it with staff. A single slide at staff induction showing what volunteers contribute beyond their hours gives teams a different picture of the people working alongside them.

Share it with leadership. Volunteer experience belongs in conversations about funding and risk, not only operations.

Then decide what to protect. This isn't permission to treat volunteers as a donor pipeline. They already give their time, skills and knowledge. Asking for more without care puts the trust that drives their giving at risk. What about the volunteers? Ask that question before any new ask goes out.

Build it so it lasts. The connection only holds if it doesn't depend on one person remembering to check. That means a shared view of supporters across volunteering and fundraising, a regular habit of matching the data and agreed ownership of the relationship.

Your volunteer program is telling you something about your funding base. Most organisations haven't connected the records to hear it.

If you matched your volunteer and donor lists next week, what do you think you'd find?


Not sure which problem you have?

If nobody can see the whole relationship with people who give you both time and money, let’s talk.

You’ll leave with a clearer view of where the pressure is coming from and whether you need us at all.

No comments yet