Applying a Customer Mindset to a Volunteer Program

Many organisations that deliver services through volunteers invest in understanding the experience of the people they serve. They gather feedback, review processes and look for gaps. It's worth asking whether the same discipline is applied to volunteers.

Not as a criticism. As a question. Because if it isn't, the organisation may be working from assumptions about what volunteers expect, what their experience has been and whether it's working. That's a reasonable starting point. But it's worth knowing whether those assumptions hold.

What gets in the way

Volunteer programs that struggle with engagement or consistency are often described as having a "volunteer problem." When you look more closely, the issue often sits in how the organisation listens, or whether it does at all. Volunteers have expectations. Their experience either meets those expectations or it doesn't. The question is whether your organisation has a way of finding out.

Three responsibilities worth considering

Applying a customer mindset to your volunteer program means taking on three responsibilities.

Understanding what volunteers expect before they start. What do they expect from the role, from the organisation and from the process of joining? These expectations are formed early and shape everything that follows.

Finding out what the experience has actually been. Not through a general survey at the end of the year, but through deliberate, structured conversations that create space for volunteers to say what's working and what isn't.

Acting on what you hear. Listening without a feedback loop doesn't build trust. What happens after volunteers share their experience is as important as the listening itself.

What volunteers typically expect

Volunteers generally expect accurate and detailed information about the role and what it requires. They expect appropriate preparation: an induction that actually prepares them and training that makes sense for the work. And they expect the process of joining to be respectful of their time.

The recruitment process is worth treating as the first opportunity to understand those expectations, not just to screen candidates. A conversation early in the process about what someone is hoping for and what they need to succeed in the role gives the organisation information it can act on.

How to find out about experience

There are several ways to gather this. Which you use depends on what you're trying to understand.

Completing a shift alongside volunteers gives a firsthand view of what the role involves day to day. It's one of the most direct ways to understand what volunteers are navigating that might not be visible from the outside.

A Voice of the Volunteer session, a structured group conversation I developed for this purpose, brings together a small group of volunteers in the same role to share experiences they might not raise individually. It also has the added benefit of connecting volunteers with each other, which matters for the quality of the experience beyond the session itself.

A Volunteer Advisory Committee creates an ongoing structure for volunteer input into the organisation. The value depends on how seriously the organisation acts on what it hears and how clearly it communicates what has changed as a result.

Regular surveys provide breadth. They're most useful when they ask specific questions: what's working well, what could be stronger, what one thing would make the biggest difference.

Three questions worth returning to

Whatever method you use, these three questions are worth building into how you work with volunteers regularly.

·       What's working well?

·       What could be stronger?

·       What one specific improvement would make the biggest difference?

They shift the conversation from assumption to evidence.

The broader question

The organisations that handle volunteer experience well tend to treat it the way they treat any other service-delivery question: with structure, with discipline and with a genuine commitment to acting on what they find.

Whether that's in place in your organisation is worth knowing.

Have you ever thought about considering a volunteer as though they were your customer? Do they have an expectation about your volunteer program? Yes, absolutely. It doesn’t matter where they volunteer and what role they undertake, volunteers are customers of your volunteer program and they come with a unique set of expectations.

Our Responsibility to the Customer (Volunteer)

As Volunteer Managers it is important that we invest time to:

  • Understand the needs and expectations of our volunteers;
  • Find out about their experiences (positive and negative); and
  • Continuously look for ways to improve the volunteer program and their volunteer experience.

Volunteer Recruitment Process

Typically we are able to learn about the general expectations of volunteers during the recruitment process. For instance on an application form or as an interview question, you may have asked 'what are you hoping to achieve by volunteering in this role?'; or 'why do you want to volunteer with us?'. Common answers often include gaining new skills and experiences, helping others, making friends and doing something fulfilling with their time.

Often if those expectations are not met, volunteers will leave and offer their time elsewhere. It is helpful to review the reasons why people choose to volunteer at your organisation and reflect on if your program provides opportunities for those expectations to be met.

What is Working Well and Opportunities for Improvement

To understand more specific expectations, experiences and opportunities to improve; it is important to speak directly with your volunteers, just like we would in a customer service environment. The three most important questions to ask are:

  • What is working well?
  • Where are the areas we could improve on?
  • What improvements could we implement?

Customer Feedback: Useful Approaches With Volunteers

Some of the approaches I have found useful to find out this information include:

  • Taking a walk in your volunteers’ shoes by completing a volunteer shift. Sometimes this is the best way to really experience the highs and lows of a volunteer role.
  • Facilitating a focus group or ‘Voice of the Volunteer’ session for a specific role / program. This has the additional benefit of providing another avenue for volunteers to meet and share common experiences.
  • Developing a Volunteer Advisory Committee with members represented from each volunteer role can facilitate a link between the volunteers and the organisation. By inviting senior staff members to attend relevant meetings you can also raise the profile of the volunteers and the good work they do.
  • Regularly conducting volunteer surveys provides an opportunity for volunteers to contribute honest and anonymous feedback and to gain valuable data to demonstrate how your program is tracking.

Are you happy to share your experiences with giving your volunteers a voice? What approaches have you taken and what were your experiences?


Not sure which problem you have?

If the data doesn’t add up, the same issues keep coming back or leadership can’t see what’s happening, let’s talk.

You’ll leave with a clearer view of where the pressure is coming from and whether you need us at all.

10 Comments

  1. Ken Velten
    Some really good suggestions especially about taking a volunteer shift. You will learn first hand what is happening.
    1. Christine ✓
      Hi Ken Thanks for your enthusiasm. It’s always great to hear from people who are passionate about volunteerism.
  2. Jackson Rob
    Thanks for joining the volunteer management blogging community. I look forward to reading more in the future
    1. Christine ✓
      Thanks Rob! I attended one of your presentations in Melbourne last year and thoroughly enjoyed it.
  3. Katherine Arnup
    Hi Christine, I’m excited to see your new initiative. I’ve been a volunteer for much of my life and, most recently, a hospice volunteer for the past 15 years. I’m also a retired academic and I’ve done a bunch of interviews with hospice volunteers about why they volunteer, what they need to support them, and what causes them to leave (if they do leave). I have a hospice volunteering blog you might be interested in – http://hospicevolunteering.wordpress.com and I’ve written several papers for conferences on these issues. It would be great to connect and share resources! Katherine
    1. Christine ✓
      Hi Katherine Thanks for connecting and sharing your blog. I look forward to hearing your perspective on upcoming posts.
  4. Lindsay Kelso
    I just send out a end of year “volunteer satisfaction survey” to see how the volunteers felt about their experience the previous year. I kept the survey anonymous, that way they could be completely honest about the good and the bad. I have gotten some very good feedback about things we can improve on and also some encouragement. I would highly recommend giving volunteers a survey and really listening to their feedback. Try to show them how you are making progress towards those improvements. It will make them feel good that you are actually following through with their suggestions.
    1. Christine ✓
      Hi Lindsay It’s fantastic to hear your annual surveys are providing an avenue for volunteers to provide honest feedback and contribute to the improvement of the program. Great work!
  5. Cindy
    I look forward to reading more.
  6. Alta
    Howdy! This is my first visit to your blog! We are a team of volunteers and starting a new initiative in the community in the same niche. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on. You have done a extraordinary job!